To the Editor:
When talking about water pollution problems caused by livestock operations, Minnesota State Representative Al Juhnke of Willmar wants to blame our state's smaller livestock operations.
"Smaller feedlots frankly are our biggest problems because of where they are located," he said during a hearing on legislation he is proposing to weaken the environmental standards for Minnesota's largest factory farms over 1,000 animal units. He offered no proof of this; probably because there is none.
He also said that these large farms are "good stewards" and shouldn't need to get a National Pollution Discharge Elimination System permit. This Federal Clean Water Act permit is an important enforcement tool for the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency and currently required for the less than 4 percent of feedlots over 1,000 animal units. In fact, it was the NPDES permit that finally shut down the Excel Dairy - a dairy near Thief River Falls that violated air quality standards hundreds of times.
These violations were so bad that it drove neighbors from their homes and the operation was declared a public health hazard by the Minnesota Department of Health. The manure still sits in the multi-million gallon manure lagoons, and may have to be cleaned up at taxpayer cost. It sounds to me like we need to strengthen standards for these so-called "good stewards," not weaken them.
It is unfortunate that we need to continue fighting legislation like this. Favoring our state's largest farms while blaming smaller livestock operations are not the values that I share. Calling small livestock farmers the "culprits" is just wrong. After all, small feedlots are not causing neighbors to evacuate their homes. As a family farm worker, I oppose Rep. Al Juhnke's bill and attitude that bigger is better.
Brad Trom
Blooming Prairie
Letters to the Editor
Letter: Don't put pollution blame on small livestock farms
Originally published in the April 16, 2010, print edition.
- Letters to the Editor
-
-
Letter: Coveting thy neighbor's stuff
Letter: Coveting thy neighbor's stuff
-
Letter: God is love - God loves Hispanics, too
Some think we should follow Arizona's horrible example. They call undocumented immigrants "criminals."
-
Letter: Research doesn't show organic foods are better
As a conventional beef producer, I take great satisfaction in producing beef that is a great value, and also safe, wholesome and nutritious.
-
Letter: Don't put pollution blame on small livestock farms
When talking about water pollution problems caused by livestock operations, Minnesota State Representative Al Juhnke of Willmar wants to blame our state's smaller livestock operations.
-
Letter: Juhnke passing false blame to pass proposal
Family farmers and rural residents need to know that Rep. Al Juhnke of Willmar is proposing legislation that will weaken environmental standards for the largest farms in our state. As a livestock farmer and registered nurse, that concerns me and I think it is wrong.
-
Letter: Encourage the weak to give them a chance
"You cannot strengthen the weak by weakening the strong." However, we also must note that in order to encourage the weak you must give them a chance to have some opportunity to achieve a decent livelihood.
-
Letter: Scare tactics misrepresent ethanol’s impact
After watching the KSTP newscast on ethanol, I believe the newscasters seem to have torn a page from Orson Welles’ recipe on how to boost their audience numbers.
-
Letter: The rest of the organic, beef labeling story
Unlike the label “organic” — which requires you to be certified — the perception of what is “natural” has definitely been highjacked and is a totally misused and maligned at the meat counter.
-
Letter: ‘Socialism’ essential to farmers, American way of life
We farmers and our lobbyists have often made it quite clear to our legislators that socialism and its accompanying federal dollars are essential to our well-being.
-
Letter: Health care questions for Walz
Would you explain just how the bill saves money on health care when you add 50 million to the number to be taken care of. Do you ration the use of tests or procedures, expensive drugs, etc.?
- More Letters to the Editor Headlines
-
Letter: Coveting thy neighbor's stuff
