Current Edition
Commentary: What’s the real cost of global warming taxes?
Originally published in the November 13, 2009, print edition.
The leftish Brookings Institution and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce basically agree that the energy taxes in the House Waxman-Markey bill could total $9 trillion over 10 years. As an economist, I look at these forecasts and wonder “How can we possibly know?”
These estimates cover only the costs of the “user permits” that companies will have to buy. They don’t even try to measure the massive reduction in our economic output as energy costs double and triple with scarcity.
Let’s look at a couple of “case studies.”
First, we use a lot of natural gas to make fertilizer, pulling 90 million tons per year of natural nitrogen from the air (which is 78 percent N). The world has only about one-third of the cow manure needed to nourish today’s crops, so nitrogen fertilizer is feeding 2 billion of the world’s 6.5 billion people through higher food yields per acre.
Imagine that 10 years from now the carbon taxes have eliminated half of the nitrogen fertilizer: global food production has fallen massively — say by 25 to 30 percent; world food prices have tripled; and storage bins are empty. What price would we pay to keep the other half of the nitrogen fertilizer so our children won’t starve?
Would farmers and the public defend the remaining fertilizer factories with roadblocks — or even firearms? Will governments overcome the “fertilizer fanatics” with force? How would the governments convince troops to fire on their own people? By giving the troops food the public can’t get?
Moreover, the BBC has just admitted what careful observers already knew — the planet hasn’t warmed since 1998. Many climatologists say we’re in a 30-year cooling driven by Pacific Ocean cycling. Will “global warming” come to be viewed as just a “weapon of mass taxation”?
Second case: Britain is supposed to lose 40 percent of its electrical generating capacity in the next eight years. All but one of its nuclear plants is due for decommissioning, and the EU declares that nine of its big coal-fired plants emit too much CO2. As the blackouts spread across a shivering winter countryside, will the UK government carry through its fossil-reduction commitments while elderly people are dying in their homes?
None of the taxes, remember, will bring fossil fuel use down enough to actually forestall man-made global warming — even if the embattled Greenhouse Theory was valid. The energy taxes will be “all pain and no gain.”
Remember, too, that the “Green alternatives” aren’t working out well.
Denmark’s massive investment in wind turbines has produced electricity mainly at night, when no one wants it.
Biofuels nearly doubled world food prices when the U.S. corn ethanol plants were all running. The proposed energy taxes will quickly drive gasoline and corn back up to food-inflation levels again. They’re supposed to.
Meanwhile, the natural, moderate 1,500-year climate cycle predicts only 0.5 degree Celsius of warming over the next several centuries. The ice cores and seabed fossils tell us this has all happened many times in the past — including five natural global warmings in the last 9,000 years.
Politicians can pass fossil fuel taxes through today’s “tame” legislatures — but they can’t make the public obey those laws after they clearly begin to violate human rights and common sense.
This commentary was submitted by Dennis Avery, a senior fellow for the Hudson Institute in Washington, D.C., and the director for the Center for Global Food Issues. He was formerly a senior analyst for the Department of State. Readers may write him at P.O. Box 202, Churchville, VA 24421 or e-mail to cgfi@hughes.net.
- Current Edition
-
-
Cover story: Threshing show brings back bygone era
From its humble origins at a 1976 Bicentennial celebration, the Hanley Falls Pioneer Power threshing show has become a popular demonstration of vintage farm equipment.
-
Back Roads: Breathtaking
Inspiration Peak, Urbank
-
Cover story: The ABCs of the Minnesota State Fair
A new game at the Great Minnesota Get-together is sure to entertain and educate young and old alike
-
Back Roads: Threshtoration project
Atwater Threshing Days, Atwater
-
Cover story: Oldies but goodies — Antique tractor clubs a growing Minnesota tradition
On any given summer weekend, Minnesotans most likely could enjoy a Minnesota Antique Tractor Club event somewhere.
-
Back Roads: Preserve & protect
You don’t need a spotting scope to watch swans but the high quality scope allowed us to look right into the gold and black eyes of a drake ring neck duck preening himself in the lily pads.
-
Cover story: Hay Day brings in varied customers
Gary Hotovec sees the dynamic of that change over the 16 years that he has run a Wednesday “Hay Day” sale at his Hutchinson auction center. He shut down the auction center last year, but has maintained the hay sales.
-
Back Roads: Twisted memorial
If you think the sculpture at 5th Street and Highway 14 in Tracy looks like scrap metal that’s been twisted by a tornado, you’ve got the right idea. But there’s more to it than that.
-
From the Fields: Folks busy with farm, family
Sure, 270 dairy cows, 200 beef cows and 850 acres of corn, wheat, alfalfa and grass seeding still keep the schedule of Bennie Holtz, 25, a bit full. But a little rascal named Brooklyn Ann who came into the world June 3 at 6 pounds 15 1/2 ounces and 20-inches long is now the top priority. Brittany, 24, and mother of this newest addition couldn’t be more pleased.
-
Back Roads: Bless the (iron) beasts
When Barb Becker was young, the church was in the heart of Moran Township’s prosperous dairy farming region. Those were less secular times than today and, for some, bringing their Farmall C and oat seed in to be blessed was as important as a visit to their banker. Who, after all, plays a larger role in the success of your crop? The Lord or the bank?
- More Current Edition Headlines
-
